Tuesday, December 4, 2012
silence
PART 1)
I found that this experiment was not as difficult as I though it was going to be. It was hard to get started but once my sister started talking, all I did was nod and agree by shaking my head back and forth. Then I would smile, forwn or make some sort of face expression that went along with what she was talking about.At first my sister thought it was better that I did not talking at all. She kept talking and I kept agreeing and shaking my head but towards the end of the conversation it looked like she wa beginning to get annoyed. She began to say shorter statements and eventually she just started asking questions where it was easier for me to just nod my head. Her behavior did alter and it was pretty ineteresting to watch her go from enjoying the conversation to just waiting for it to be over. If we were two different cultures trying to communicate my sister the speaking one would have the advantage over the non speaking and symbolic one. People who are deaf have a hard time communiacting with our culture because we as a whole do not understand sign language. People who do speak try to imitate what the hearing impared are trying to say or they try to act out or point at the object that they are trying to get across. I know that I have experienced this when I worked at a retail store I had an impaired woman come in and she immediately let me know that she was deaf by pointing at her ear. Then she took out a notepad and began writting to me what she wanted to buy.
PART 2)
I was actually only able to last about eight minutes. Although I was able to freely talk I wasn't allowed to put any emotion behind it or use any hand movements. This was harder than I thought it was going to be because as much as I wanted to keep the conversation going not being able to put any emotion or facial expressions in my conversation made it a lot more difficult. My sister first laughed at me and said I sounded like a robot, but then she said it was harder for her to communicate with me than the first time. I actually found that it was harder as well. I never noticed how important our signs and face expressions were to our culture and language. I believe that this says that we as humans have to have some type of emotion when we speak in order to communicate properly. Autistic people cannot read body language or facial expressions. The advantage of being able to read someones body language is that you are able to tell what kind of mood theyre in if theyre crossing their hands they might me mad. Things like this help us read each other without actually speaking to one another. An environment where it might not be beneficial to read body language might be in a court house. If the jury cannot read your body language , and if you are nervous they will not be able to tell. I don't know it was a little more difficult thinking of one so that's my best. Over all I really enjoyed this experiment and actually learned a lot from it.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I certainly like your suggestion for the advantageous gesture-blindness (of course, it's probably most useful if you're guilty!). Still, the advantage for the defendant only applies to the ineptitude of the jury. If the defendant were unable to read body language, it could lead to the defendant being unable to properly express him or herself on the stand. As I thought about this more, though, prosecutors often use body language to provoke defendants into acting irrationally. It might allow the defendant to stay calm and avoid any legal traps.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading the progression of your conversation and following the change in your sister's response. Good discussion as well in terms of the cultural advantage of spoken language. One clarification: Spoken language IS symbolic language. Body language is a form of signs. To make it more confusing, American Sign Language is actually a form of symbolic language.
ReplyDeleteStudents are always surprised how difficult Part B is. Most assume that since you are able to speak, it will be easy, but it is always the more difficult of the two experiments, particularly for the partners.
Great catch on the issue of autism and the ability to read body language! That is precisely the group I had in mind with this question.
Great post!